Why is the stain in a different room from the leak?
Because water runs downhill inside the roof space before it finds a way through the ceiling. It follows the slope of the deck, then a rafter, then the top of the insulation, and it drops wherever there is a gap.
A roof is a sloped plane over a flat ceiling with a void between them that is full of framing, insulation, ducts and wiring. Water that gets in at the top of a slope may travel some distance before it meets a seam in the ceiling board, a light fitting or a duct penetration. That is where it appears.
This also explains a stain that comes back after it has been painted over. If the insulation above is still wet, the ceiling board is being fed from above every time the humidity in the roof space rises, and no amount of sealing the paint will change that.
Does the roofer come before or after the restoration crew?
They overlap. Drying work usually starts first because wet insulation and ceiling board get worse by the hour, while the roofer closes the opening, often with a temporary cover until the weather allows a repair.
The two trades are doing different jobs. A roofer is responsible for the covering, the flashings and the deck. A restoration crew is responsible for everything the water reached on its way down: insulation, ceiling board, the top of the wall below, and the floor if it got that far.
Each benefits from the other's notes. A roofer who knows where the wet insulation was found has a much better idea of where to look on the roof, and a crew that knows which detail failed knows whether to expect one wet patch or a line of them.
What affects the cost of a roof leak repair inside the house?
How many rooms the water reached, how much insulation is saturated, how much ceiling board has to come out, the ceiling height and the access. The scope is explained and approved before work begins and no figure is quoted on this site.
A single wet patch in a single-story house with an accessible attic hatch is the straightforward end. It gets harder when the wet band crosses rooms, when the ceiling is vaulted with no void to work in, when the ceiling is at the top of a stairwell, or when the house is two stories and the wet area is over a landing.
The age of the building plays a part too. In an older house with different ceiling materials or layered finishes, more care goes into opening up, and a crew checks what it is cutting into before it starts. Anything found during the work is reported as it is found.
Can wet attic insulation be dried instead of replaced?
Rarely. Insulation works by holding still air, and water replaces that air; once soaked it loses its value and holds moisture against the framing and the ceiling board. In a closed attic it has almost no chance to dry.
There is also very little air movement up there in winter, which is the one thing drying depends on. A wet patch of batt insulation sitting on the back of a ceiling in a closed roof space can stay damp for the rest of the wet season, and it will keep the board below it damp with it.
So the saturated portion is removed and the rest is left alone. Putting new insulation back is a separate, later job, and it is done after the readings confirm the framing and the ceiling are dry, not on the same visit.
What about the wall below a wet ceiling?
It is checked as a matter of course. Water that reaches the top plate of a wall runs down inside the cavity and can wet the drywall, the insulation and the baseboard a long way below the ceiling stain.
Readings are taken at several heights on the wall rather than only at the top, since water in a cavity sometimes bypasses the upper section entirely and shows up at the bottom. Where the cavity is wet and closed, a small opening low down lets it drain and dry rather than sitting against the framing.
The same logic carries on to the floor. Carpet and pad at the base of a wall that has been fed from above are often wet without anybody noticing, and that is checked before the equipment is placed. Ceiling and drywall water damage goes further into what happens to the finishes.